In December 2024, after dark in the middle of Los Olivos, Keith Saarloos called the children up to the town Christmas tree. The Santa Ynez Valley Star reported that he had them place their hands on it and make a wish. The wish was not for themselves but for someone else. Then the crowd counted down from ten and the tree lit up.
That tree was new that year, and it stood 35 feet tall. According to the same Valley Star account, Saarloos used the moment to thank the many people who had contributed financially to buying it. The tree belongs to the town, and it gets lit again this year on Saturday, December 5. The next afternoon, Mattei's Tavern holds a second tree lighting on Railway Avenue. That one has a ticket price, and every ticket sale goes to a charity.
So the village opens its season twice in about 24 hours, and the two evenings are funded in different ways. Knowing which is which makes it easier to plan the weekend.
The tree in the middle of town
Olde Fashioned Christmas goes back decades. In December 2014 the Santa Barbara Independent called it "now in its 34th year," which puts the first one around 1981. That preview set the tree lighting at the flagpole. It also described Santa visits, crafts, train rides, live Christmas music, and retailers, tasting rooms and restaurants staying open late.
Ten years later the shape was much the same. The Valley Star's account of the 2024 edition says the Los Olivos Chamber sponsored the event. The town spent the afternoon in its shops and tasting rooms and then gathered in the middle of town for the lighting. The Los Olivos Rotary handed out cookies and cocoa. "This is our favorite event of the year," Rotary president Alice Berg told the Valley Star. "We love giving out cookies and cocoa to the community; it gets us all into the holiday spirit."
Everything about the Saturday event points back to the tree. The whole village is the venue, the evening ends at the flagpole, and the tree itself was paid for by the people standing around it.
Saturday, December 5: the whole village
The 2026 date is posted on the Los Olivos visitor site as Saturday, December 5. Andrew Murray Vineyards lists the event from 3 to 7 p.m. and is hosting at its E11even Tasting Room in downtown Los Olivos. Its listing offers a glass of wine and a sweet treat as guests walk through town, along with festive music and a community celebration in the park. The town tree is lit at 6 p.m.
Here is how the afternoon went in 2024, according to the Valley Star:
- Shops offered holiday deals and tasting rooms poured through the afternoon.
- A local jazz band played Christmas tunes.
- Figueroa Mountain Brewery hosted a holiday market and crafts, a cookie-decorating table for kids, hot cocoa and free photos with Santa.
- St. Mark's-in-the-Valley Episcopal Church held a Gingerbread Wonderland, with work by local artisans and schoolchildren displayed on tables.
- The St. Mark's Choir led carols as the crowd moved toward the tree.
- Music and dancing continued after the lighting.
The 2024 version had no single venue and no ticket. The 6 p.m. lighting is the only fixed point on the schedule, and the three hours before it are spread across the businesses along the village streets.
Sunday, December 6: one courtyard and a $10 ticket
Mattei's Tavern runs its own tree lighting the next day, Sunday, December 6, from 4 to 6 p.m. at The Inn at Mattei's Tavern, 2350 Railway Avenue. The Santa Ynez Valley Foundation's event calendar describes hot cocoa and warm cider, ornament decorating for kids, Christmas cookies and live music. The courtyard gets snow, stagecoach rides, a photobooth and a holiday marketplace of local artisans.
Tickets are $10 per person, and all ticket sales are donated to People Helping People. Visit Santa Ynez Valley lists the same date and times and names the Inn as the organizer.
Saturday's money already went into the tree before anyone arrives. Sunday's money goes out through the ticket, to an organization that serves the wider valley. Sunday is also more compact. It runs two hours in one courtyard, so it is the easier choice for anyone with small children and an early bedtime, or anyone who wants a tree lighting without Saturday's three-hour walk.
Planning around both, plus a third set of lights in Buellton
The first weekend of December is busier than these two evenings. The SYV Holiday Lights display at the Santa Ynez Valley Botanic Garden in Buellton opens the same weekend. It runs December 4–6, 11–13 and 18–20, 2026, and tickets are sold through the event's own site.
| Olde Fashioned Christmas | Mattei's Annual Tree Lighting | SYV Holiday Lights | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Date | Saturday, Dec. 5, 2026 | Sunday, Dec. 6, 2026 | Dec. 4–6, 11–13 and 18–20, 2026 |
| Hours | 3–7 p.m., tree lit at 6 p.m. | 4–6 p.m. | Ticketed nights |
| Where | Throughout the village, tree at the flagpole | The Inn at Mattei's Tavern, 2350 Railway Ave. | Santa Ynez Valley Botanic Garden, Buellton |
| Cost | No ticket listed | $10 per person | Tickets online |
| Where the money goes | Tree funded by community contributions | All ticket sales to People Helping People | Event tickets |
On the opening weekend, a household could see the Botanic Garden lights Friday, the flagpole tree Saturday and the Mattei's courtyard Sunday. Later December weekends belong to Buellton's display alone.
A new stop before the 3 p.m. start
This is Lucky Penny's first December in Los Olivos. The Santa Barbara pizza restaurant opened its second location in mid-May at 2902 San Marcos Avenue, the longtime home of Corner House Coffee, Noozhawk reported. It is open 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. daily.
Those hours cover Saturday's full event window and the time after the tree is lit. Noozhawk listed a "Good Morning" menu that includes a Savory Breakfast Bowl, Ricotta Toast and a baked-to-order Dutch Baby. The pizzas include the East Coast Pepperoni, the Californian and the Butcher Shop. There are also coffee and tea drinks, grab-and-go snacks, and pastries from Helena Avenue Bakery. When the opening was first announced in January, the restaurant's general manager, Morgan Gray, told Noozhawk that the team wanted "a casual, welcoming gathering place for locals and visitors alike."
For the Olde Fashioned Christmas crowd, that means a family that eats on San Marcos Avenue before 3 p.m. is already in the village when the shops and tasting rooms open for the afternoon.
Mattei's after the second tree
The Sunday lighting is the start of a longer holiday program at the Inn. Mattei's Tavern has published a Christmas itinerary that it calls an aspirational guide to a holiday stay. The announced plans include:
- Thursday, December 24: letters to Santa, cookie decorating, a cocktail workshop and stagecoach rides.
- Friday, December 25: a buffet-style Christmas dinner from 3 to 9 p.m.
- Saturday, December 26: charcuterie-board and sparkling-wine activities.
The flagpole tree was bought with community contributions, and no ticket is listed for its lighting. Sunday's courtyard evening turns $10 tickets into a donation to People Helping People. The late-December dates at Mattei's are part of its holiday stay. Doors open on San Marcos Avenue from 8 a.m., and Saturday's lighting is at 6 p.m. sharp.
The tree at the flagpole was paid for by the community that gathers around it. If you own property here, or are considering a quiet sale or purchase in the village, Stormo Homes would be glad to meet over coffee this season. Request a Private Consultation, and Nina will share what she knows about the parcels and the people that make Los Olivos what it is.